Skip to content
G&G Technologies 201-791-1400 Search Cart

Streaming a Church Service: Choosing the Encoder, Switcher and Camera

Short answer. One camera going to YouTube and Facebook at the same time: the Magewell Ultra Stream HDMI, which streams to two servers at once. Two to four cameras plus the slides computer: the Blackmagic ATEM Mini Pro, a switcher with the encoder built in. Up to eight sources: the ATEM Mini Extreme. One box with a touch screen, XLR inputs for the sound desk and streaming to several platforms: the Epiphan Pearl Mini. For the camera, the Panasonic AG-CX20 camcorder has a 24x zoom for a tripod at the back of the room. The ATEM Mini Pro is the lowest-priced pick here, and this page has no PTZ cameras.

The 5 Picks

Encoder
Switcher with encoder
All-in-one
Camera
Video
1 HDMI in, with loop-through
4 HDMI in
8 HDMI in
1 3G-SDI, 2 HDMI, 2 USB in, plus NDI|HX
HDMI and SDI out
Audio in
Analog mic input
2 x 3.5 mm stereo
2 x 3.5 mm stereo
2 XLR, 2 quarter-inch TRS
2 XLR, line, mic or 48 V phantom
Streams to
2 servers at once, RTMP or RTMPS
RTMP or SRT over Ethernet
RTMP or SRT over Ethernet
Many destinations; SRT, RTMPS, HLS
Through your encoder or switcher
Records to
32 GB internal, USB drive or phone
USB disk, H.264 MP4
USB disk, H.264 MP4
Internal SSD or SD card
2 SD card slots
Notable
Control: Buttons, phone app or browser
Not listed
Multiview: Up to 16 views
Control: 7-inch touch screen, one-touch start
Zoom: 24x optical
Use it for
One camera, or the HDMI output of a switcher, sent to YouTube and Facebook at the same time, because it streams to 2 servers at once and passes the HDMI signal through to a monitor.
Two to four cameras plus a slides computer, streamed to one platform with no computer in the chain, because it switches 4 HDMI inputs and streams over Ethernet.
A larger service with more cameras and computers, because it takes 8 HDMI inputs and shows up to 16 of them on one monitor.
One box that switches, streams to several platforms and records, run from a touch screen, with XLR inputs for the sound desk.
The camera at the back of the room, because its 24x zoom gives a close shot from a distance and it sends HDMI to an ATEM or SDI to a Pearl Mini.
Price
$529.00
$445.00
$1,249.00
$3,750.00
$2,949.00
Encoder
Magewell Ultra Stream HDMI Streaming Encoder (53010)
Magewell Ultra Stream HDMI Streaming Encoder (53010)
Specs
Video
1 HDMI in, with loop-through
Audio in
Analog mic input
Streams to
2 servers at once, RTMP or RTMPS
Records to
32 GB internal, USB drive or phone
Notable
Control: Buttons, phone app or browser
Use it for
One camera, or the HDMI output of a switcher, sent to YouTube and Facebook at the same time, because it streams to 2 servers at once and passes the HDMI signal through to a monitor.
$529.00
Switcher with encoder
Blackmagic ATEM Mini PRO Switcher
Blackmagic ATEM Mini PRO Switcher
Specs
Video
4 HDMI in
Audio in
2 x 3.5 mm stereo
Streams to
RTMP or SRT over Ethernet
Records to
USB disk, H.264 MP4
Use it for
Two to four cameras plus a slides computer, streamed to one platform with no computer in the chain, because it switches 4 HDMI inputs and streams over Ethernet.
$445.00
Blackmagic ATEM Mini Extreme Switcher
Blackmagic ATEM Mini Extreme Switcher
Specs
Video
8 HDMI in
Audio in
2 x 3.5 mm stereo
Streams to
RTMP or SRT over Ethernet
Records to
USB disk, H.264 MP4
Notable
Multiview: Up to 16 views
Use it for
A larger service with more cameras and computers, because it takes 8 HDMI inputs and shows up to 16 of them on one monitor.
$1,249.00
All-in-one
Epiphan Pearl Mini Live Production System
Epiphan Pearl Mini Live Production System
Specs
Video
1 3G-SDI, 2 HDMI, 2 USB in, plus NDI|HX
Audio in
2 XLR, 2 quarter-inch TRS
Streams to
Many destinations; SRT, RTMPS, HLS
Records to
Internal SSD or SD card
Notable
Control: 7-inch touch screen, one-touch start
Use it for
One box that switches, streams to several platforms and records, run from a touch screen, with XLR inputs for the sound desk.
$3,750.00
Camera
Panasonic AG-CX20 4K Professional Compact Camcorder
Panasonic AG-CX20 4K Professional Compact Camcorder
Specs
Video
HDMI and SDI out
Audio in
2 XLR, line, mic or 48 V phantom
Streams to
Through your encoder or switcher
Records to
2 SD card slots
Notable
Zoom: 24x optical
Use it for
The camera at the back of the room, because its 24x zoom gives a close shot from a distance and it sends HDMI to an ATEM or SDI to a Pearl Mini.
$2,949.00

Browse the Shelf

What Matters

One camera on a tripod needs no switcher: its HDMI output goes straight into an encoder such as the Magewell Ultra Stream HDMI, and one volunteer starts the stream. Two or more cameras, or a camera plus the lyrics and slides computer, need a switcher to cut between them. The ATEM Mini Pro takes 4 HDMI sources and the ATEM Mini Extreme takes 8. The Pearl Mini switches, streams and records up to three full HD inputs from 1 SDI, 2 HDMI and 2 USB ports.

For one platform, yes. Blackmagic lists direct streaming from the ATEM Mini Pro and Mini Extreme over Ethernet with RTMP or SRT, to YouTube, Facebook and Twitch, with no computer in the chain. Both record the program to a USB disk as an H.264 MP4. Blackmagic does not list streaming to two platforms at once, so when the service has to reach two, run the switcher's HDMI output into an encoder that does, or use the Pearl Mini.

Each platform is its own stream, set up with the server address and stream key that platform gives you. Magewell lists the Ultra Stream HDMI as streaming to 2 servers at once, each one YouTube, Facebook, Twitch or a custom RTMP or RTMPS server. Epiphan says the Pearl Mini streams to many destinations, each set up the same way. For the church website, YouTube's own help suggests embedding the live stream on your site, so the YouTube stream can fill the player there and the second stream can go to Facebook. Every extra stream needs more upload speed from the church internet connection, so run the full set once before a Sunday.

Take the stream's audio from an output on the sound desk, not from a microphone on the camera. The ATEM Mini Pro and Mini Extreme each have two 3.5 mm stereo inputs. The Pearl Mini has two XLR and two quarter-inch TRS inputs. The AG-CX20 has two XLR inputs, each switchable between line, mic and mic with 48 V phantom power, and the sound travels with the picture over HDMI or SDI. The Ultra Stream HDMI has an analog microphone input only, so with it the desk feeds the camera or switcher first.

A recording keeps the sermon if the stream drops and gives you a file to post later. The ATEM Mini Pro and Mini Extreme record the program to a USB disk. The Ultra Stream HDMI records to its 32 GB internal storage, a USB flash drive or a linked phone. The Pearl Mini records up to three 1080p streams to an internal SSD or an SD card you supply. The AG-CX20 has two SD card slots and can record to both at once.

Pick the box the least technical person on the schedule can start. Blackmagic made the ATEM Mini source buttons large enough to switch by feel. The Ultra Stream HDMI runs from buttons on the unit, a phone app or a web browser. The Pearl Mini has a 7-inch touch screen with a one-touch button on the front screen for recording and streaming.

Questions

It depends on how many cameras you run and how many platforms you stream to. One camera to YouTube and Facebook at once: the Magewell Ultra Stream HDMI, which streams to 2 servers. Up to four cameras to one platform: the ATEM Mini Pro, a switcher with the encoder built in. Several platforms, a touch screen and XLR inputs in one box: the Epiphan Pearl Mini.

One that streams by itself, so you do not buy a separate encoder. The ATEM Mini Pro takes 4 HDMI sources and the ATEM Mini Extreme takes 8; both stream over Ethernet with RTMP or SRT and record to a USB disk. To reach two platforms at once, feed the switcher's HDMI output into an encoder such as the Ultra Stream HDMI.

A camcorder with a long zoom and an output that matches your switcher or encoder. The Panasonic AG-CX20 has a 24x zoom, HDMI and SDI outputs, and two XLR inputs for a feed from the sound desk. This page has no PTZ cameras; the PTZ shelf lists them.

Questions? Talk to a Person.

Call (201) 791-1400 or email [email protected] - we've handled pro audio & video since 1988.